Follow on LinkedIn ↗
GEOPOLITICS · POWER · GLOBAL AFFAIRS
The Weekly Column · Opinion

A summit is not a title deed

Trump, Xi and Putin can discuss the world. They do not own it.

Fictional editorial satire: Trump, Xi and Putin join hands around a round table like participants at a séance, with a crystal globe of Earth in the centre.
Is anybody else there? Original AI-generated editorial satire · 18 November 2026. A fictional metaphor, not a depiction of an actual meeting.

I am writing these lines a few hours before 19 November: my 52nd birthday, and the day Trump, Xi and Putin are expected to meet in Shenzhen. I had not put a new world order on my birthday list.

I want them to talk. I would rather see difficult conversations than dangerous miscalculations. But assembling enough power in one room does not give its occupants a mandate over everyone outside it.

The three leaders can discuss Ukraine. They cannot supply Ukraine’s consent. That distinction should survive every flattering phrase about a historic meeting, a breakthrough or a new international order.

For Europe, the answer cannot simply be indignation about the seating plan. A place at the table matters when it comes with something the negotiation needs: sustained support, credible security commitments and the capacity to carry them out. Demanding consultation while leaving the difficult commitments to others would be a thin strategy.

Nor should we confuse an agreement among leaders with a peace that people can live under. I would judge any proposal by whether those affected can accept it, whether its guarantees can be enforced and whether it reduces the incentive to use force again. A polished communiqué will answer none of those questions on its own.

As of this evening, the meeting is still ahead of us. Its outcome is open. The standard by which we judge it need not be.

Let the presidents negotiate. Let them produce something worth examining. But the rest of us should remember that a summit is a meeting, not a title deed.

Sources